Have you ever wondered if there is a smarter way to own property and protect your family’s wealth? Many Australians are turning to family trusts as a way to hold assets, reduce risk, and plan for the future. At first glance, it can sound like the perfect solution. But before you rush in, it’s important to weigh both the benefits and the drawbacks.
This article will break down what it really means to buy property in a family trust, the advantages and disadvantages you should be aware of, and some practical tips to avoid costly mistakes.
What Does It Mean to Own Property in a Family Trust?
When property is held in a family trust, it is not owned in your personal name. Instead, the trustee holds the legal title on behalf of the beneficiaries, following the rules of the trust deed. In simple terms, you control the trust, but the property belongs to the trust structure, not to you directly.
Before a trust can hold property, the trust deed must clearly allow it, and the trustee must have authority to borrow, mortgage, and deal with the property. Titles must also be registered properly, showing that the trustee is acting in that capacity. If any of these steps are mishandled, it can lead to serious legal and tax issues later.
The Potential Advantages of Buying Property in a Family Trust
Family trusts are often considered because of the unique benefits they can provide. Here are some of the main reasons Australians choose this path:
Asset protection
Holding property in a family trust can help shield it from personal creditors, since it is legally owned by the trust, not by you. This can be valuable if you are in business or in a profession with a higher risk of being sued. That said, protection is not guaranteed.
Courts can still look through the structure in cases of bankruptcy or family law disputes.
Flexibility in distributing income and capital gains
Trustees have discretion in distributing rental income or capital gains among beneficiaries. This allows income to be shared in a way that may reduce the overall family tax bill, for example, by allocating more to family members in lower tax brackets.
Estate planning and continuity
When property is held in a trust, it usually does not pass through probate on your death. Instead, the trust continues operating according to its deed, avoiding delays and disputes. This can make succession smoother and reduce the chance of conflict among beneficiaries.
Ongoing ownership
Because the trust is not tied to a person’s lifespan, the property can remain under the same structure for decades. This continuity avoids repeated transfers and potential costs associated with moving assets between generations.
The Disadvantages You Need to Know About
Despite the appealing benefits, family trusts are far from perfect. There are significant downsides that could outweigh the advantages for many Australians.
Loss of concessions
One of the biggest drawbacks is the loss of tax exemptions available to individuals. Family trusts generally do not qualify for the principal place of residence exemption or first home buyer concessions. This means you could face capital gains tax on a home you live in and miss out on valuable government savings.
Land tax implications
Many states treat properties held in trusts less favourably, often removing access to tax-free thresholds and applying surcharge rates. If your trust includes foreign beneficiaries, it may even be classified as a foreign trust, which triggers further penalties and restrictions.
Financing challenges
Banks tend to view trusts as higher risk. This often means stricter borrowing conditions, additional documentation, and personal guarantees from the individuals behind the trust. In practice, even if the property is held by the trust, you may still carry the financial liability.
Trapped losses
Negative gearing benefits are lost when property is held in a trust. Any losses from the property cannot be offset against your personal income but must remain within the trust until future profits can absorb them.
Administration and compliance
Family trusts require ongoing management. Annual tax returns, trustee resolutions, and strict record-keeping are compulsory. Professional accounting and legal fees can add up over time, and failing to comply properly can create legal problems.
Family law risks
Placing property in a family trust does not automatically protect it in a divorce. Courts have the power to treat trust assets as part of the marital property pool.
A Practical Example
Consider a couple who establish a discretionary family trust and purchase an investment property. The trustee earns rental income of $30,000 per year. Distributions are made strategically, a larger share goes to the spouse on a lower income, a portion is given to an adult child, and the remainder goes to the higher-earning partner. This reduces the overall tax burden for the family.
On the surface, this looks like a win. But there are trade-offs. The couple loses access to capital gains tax exemptions if they ever decide to live in the property. They face higher land tax charges, stricter lending conditions, and cannot offset negative gearing losses against their personal income. Annual accounting fees also become another ongoing expense.
This scenario shows the balancing act. The flexibility can be attractive, but the long-term costs and restrictions may outweigh the benefits for many families.
Practical Tips Before You Commit
If you are considering holding property in a family trust, careful preparation is vital. Here are some tips to keep in mind:
Seek professional advice before setting up the structure. Laws differ between states, and a poorly drafted trust deed can cause major issues later.
- Ensure the deed allows property ownership and borrowing. The wording must be clear and legally sound.
- Be cautious with foreign beneficiaries. Even if not actively involved, their presence could expose the trust to foreign surcharges.
- Confirm bank requirements early. Lenders often insist on personal guarantees and strict serviceability rules.
- Maintain accurate records. Every resolution, distribution, and decision needs proper documentation.
- Review distributions each year. Don’t focus only on tax savings; make sure decisions comply with the deed and remain defensible.
- Think long term. Transferring property in or out of the trust later can trigger stamp duty and capital gains tax.
- Plan for worst-case scenarios. Consider what happens in cases of death, separation, or bankruptcy.
Final Thoughts
A family trust can be a powerful tool in the right circumstances. For families with significant assets, long-term investment strategies, or exposure to financial risks, it may offer tax flexibility and asset protection. But it is not a one-size-fits-all solution.
For many Australians, the loss of concessions, higher land tax, stricter borrowing conditions, and ongoing compliance costs make personal ownership more practical.
The key is to make the decision based on your actual numbers and personal circumstances, not just because it sounds like a clever strategy. With good legal and accounting advice, you can avoid expensive mistakes and decide if a family trust is the right fit for your property goals.
Disclaimer: This website is designed for informational and educational purposes. Although we exert diligent efforts to maintain the accuracy and reliability of the content, we must disclaim liability for any errors, omissions, or inaccuracies. The content provided is “as is” and is not accompanied by warranties, whether expressed or implied. It should not serve as the sole basis for financial or legal decisions.
Given the evolving nature of financial regulations and conditions, the accuracy and reliability of information may change over time. Users are urged to exercise due diligence and consult with a qualified financial professional for personalised advice. ‘Clear Tax Accountants’ bears no responsibility for direct or indirect consequences, encompassing financial loss or legal matters stemming from the use or misuse of the information on this website.
Please be aware that the information, by no means, is a substitute for financial advice.
